Mark Atherton
Teoksen Teach Yourself Old English Package (Book 2CDs) tekijä
Tietoja tekijästä
Mark Atherton is Senior Lecturer in English Language and Literature at Regent's Park College, University of Oxford, UK. He is the author of The Making of England (Bloomsbury, 2017) and Complete Old English (2019).
Tekijän teokset
Celts and Christians: New Approaches to the Religious Traditions of Britain and Ireland (University of Wales Press -… (2002) 13 kappaletta
Complete Old English Beginner to Intermediate Course: Learn to read, write, speak and understand a new language with… 2 kappaletta
Selected Writings 2 kappaletta
Associated Works
Merkitty avainsanalla
Yleistieto
- Syntymäaika
- 20th Century
- Sukupuoli
- male
Jäseniä
Kirja-arvosteluja
Palkinnot
You May Also Like
Associated Authors
Tilastot
- Teokset
- 9
- Also by
- 2
- Jäseniä
- 300
- Suosituimmuussija
- #78,268
- Arvio (tähdet)
- 3.9
- Kirja-arvosteluja
- 1
- ISBN:t
- 31
- Kielet
- 2
To be less cryptic (or is that "quiptic"?), many if most students would agree that Tom Shippey has given more insight into J. R. R. Tolkien's works than any other critic. The main reason for this is that Shippey, like Tolkien, is a philologist -- meaning that he has the special knowledge and insight to know what Tolkien was up to. So when I discovered that another philologist, Mark Atherton, had written a work on Tolkien, I was intrigued. Another scholar's philological findings could illuminate much about the Tolkien universe.
But those insights just don't come through in this book. It includes a lot of detail about Tolkien's "sources" -- but often they aren't sources, they're just influences. Tolkien might have liked the writings of John Masefield, e.g. (since both, unusually, wrote substantial poetry in alliterative verse forms rather than the more common rhymed verse) -- but there is no Masefield in The Hobbit! What makes Tolkien Tolkien is not his occasional similarities to the works of other writers, but his original treatments of ancient mythology and folklore. And Atherton, while he pays some attention to this, wraps it in so much other material that it is too easily lost.
I might be more forgiving of that if the writing were better. But this is not a particularly pleasant read. I don't mean that it contains unpleasant information, or that it is impossible to comprehend, but it is heavy enough that I couldn't read it for fun.
And what's the point of those silly drawings? Since neither I nor Atherton know what Tolkien thought a goblin looked like, why waste a page with the not-very-detailed-or-realistic image on p. 143? And if I don't know what a tree trunk looks like, then I doubt that one photo (p. 163) is going to teach me.
There is good and interesting material in here. But I eventually resorted to flipping around trying to find it. The ratio of dross to gold in this work is simply too high.… (lisätietoja)