A rather depressing look at growing up in a brutal world. And of a quest. I found it a bit too much like work to have to plough through all the difficulties faced by the pilgrims. Metaphorical agony abounds. ( )

This is the book of Poilar Crookleg, who has been to the roof of the World at the top of the Wall, who has seen the strange and bewildering gods that dwell there, who has grappled with them and returned rich with the knowledge of the mysteries of life and of death.

So begins this richly resonant novel, set on some distant planet (well, all planets are distant, aren’t they?), in a part of that world which is dominated by a inconceivably vast mountain called the Wall. From a community which is made up of distinct villages surrounding the Wall forty youngsters are chosen periodically to attempt the scaling of the mountain. Despite the honour accruing to the chosen ones, few of them ever return, and those that do seem unable to give a coherent narrative. Poilar is determined to be the one who not only achieves the ascent but to return and give an account. Despite the very first sentence providing the most monumental spoiler ever, Silverberg’s novel maintains a very palpable will-he-won’t-he tension throughout: Poilar’s nickname, Crookleg, is just one if the most obvious of the obstacles for him ever making his dream a reality.

I said that Silverberg’s fantasy is richly resonant. On all levels – mythological, anthropological, folkloric and literary – the quest by aspirant heroes to achieve an impossible task is archetypal. The forty chosen youngsters are reminiscent of Theseus and his companions setting off for Crete, its labyrinth and the Minotaur; or of Arthur’s knights questing for the grail; or of a fairytale hero such as Gluck (in John Ruskin’s The King of the Golden River) attempting to succeed in sprinkling holy water into a magnificent cataract in the face of failure by his malevolent brothers. The visible dangers that they face on the way remind me of the perils faced by Odysseus on his journey home, of the Labours of Hercules or of the perils surmounted by Perseus in classical myth; and of course the range of social interactions among Poilar’s forty companions is typical of the motifs found in many folktales. Indeed, Silverberg’s epic has the feel of a traditional tale surviving from the mists of time.

Over all looms the presence of the Wall, an overbearing but non-human character, which dominates or at least cannot be ignored in Poilar’s account. This too conforms to an archetype, that of the sacred mountain found in many cultures: Mount Meru or Kailas in Eastern myth, Ararat or Sinai in the Middle East, Olympus or maybe even Glastonbury Tor in the West. The ziggurats of Mesopotamia, built as artificial sacred mountains, recall to mind Silverberg’s earlier novel Gilgamesh the King, by all accounts a demythologised version of the Sumerian culture hero who confronts the demon Humbaba on Cedar Mountain. Kingdoms of the Wall seems like yet another take on the same theme, this time with the ‘gods’ on top of the mountain being not what was expected, in a revelation not unlike the denouement of Planet of the Apes.

The Wall is also resonant with another of Silverberg’s creations, Castle Mount in his Majipoor novels. Here too is another colossus of a geographical feature which the human beings on this alien planet have to somehow furnish with an artificial atmosphere, so high does Castle Mount reach. In Kingdoms of the Wall all the natives have to do is effect some metamorphosis of their bodies, an innate adaptive feature of their physique. In this (and in other physical features) they resemble the Metamorphs or Shapeshifters of the Majipoor series, so much so that I wonder if this novel was originally conceived as a kind of Majipoor prequel before Silverberg backed away from this approach and made it a standalone novel.

So far only the technical, structural and thematic features of this novel have detained us, but I must briefly discuss whether it delivers an emotional punch. Of the odd few Silverberg writings I’ve read many are technically intricate but strangely disengaging – I admire them for the world-building but never quite care about the mostly male protagonists (unlike, say, Ursula Le Guin, who makes you believe in the humanity of her characters). In many ways his fiction can be dryly descriptive, like his non-fiction (I particularly enjoyed his The Realm of Prester John, first published in 1972). Kingdoms of the Wall, however, is written in the first person, and spread over a few hundred pages this approach allows one some insight into the human psychology of its ostensibly alien leading man, enabling the reader to develop some empathy for him. Claude Lalumière, in A Brief History of Robert Silverberg, calls it “a deeply affecting and evocative extraterrestrial novel whose subtle and complex structure invites layered readings”. This is certainly a judgement I can agree with.

http://www.locusmag.com/2004/Reviews/10_LalumiereOnSilverberg.html
http://calmgrove.wordpress.com/2013/04/07/wall/ ( )

Le Mur est une montagne qui perce les basses couches de l'atmosphère et pointe sa cime vers l'espace. Pourtant, chaque année, quarante jeunes aventuriers partent à sa conquête dans l'espoir de parler aux dieux détenteurs de la sagesse, qui habitent son sommet presque inaccessible. Personne n'est jamais revenu. Mais Poilar Bancroche, cette année-là, a été choisi pour commander les quarante. Et affronter les royaumes du Mur qui en protègent le secret.