

Pikkukuvaa napsauttamalla pääset Google Booksiin.
Ladataan... This is the SunTekijä: Elizabeth Everett
![]() - Ei tämänhetkisiä Keskustelu-viestiketjuja tästä kirjasta. ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ei arvosteluja | lisää arvostelu
PalkinnotNotable Lists
From the tiniest animal to the tallest tree, everything on Earth is connected through the circle of life. At the center of it all is a different kind of circle--the Sun! Kirjastojen kuvailuja ei löytynyt. |
LibraryThing Early Reviewers AlumElizabeth Everett's book Este es el Sol was available from LibraryThing Early Reviewers. Current Discussions-
![]() LajityypitMelvil Decimal System (DDC)551.5271Natural sciences and mathematics Earth sciences & geology Geology, Hydrology Meteorology Meteorology; Climate Thermometry, heatArvio (tähdet)Keskiarvo:![]()
Oletko sinä tämä henkilö? |
As a science educator, I absolutely love the premise here. The science is pretty solid, though there are a few things that could have been clearer (e.g. the "bug" depicted appears to be a caterpillar and is shown eating the leaves, but for some reason the text says it's nibbling on the flower; not really sure why flowers were included at all, since the story doesn't actually take us through the tree's life cycle, just has a seed appear out of nowhere later in the story). I also would have appreciated more explicit inclusion of decomposers, a vital part of the ecosystem that's often overlooked; the author did include scat (i.e. poop), but makes no mention of its contribution beyond that the seed happens to land in it and sprout.
The writing could be stronger, especially at the beginning and end of the story. Some of the verbs aren't very punchy (the light "comes from" the sun, the tree "uses" the light to make food, the seed "comes from" the tree). It also takes a few pages to get into the cumulative rhythm, and then the tree (rather than the sun) becomes the final line of that repeating poem - which seems like an odd choice for a book titled "This is the Sun." If I were the editor here, I would have suggested an opening line like, "This is the light / that shines from the sun" followed by "This is the tree / that makes food from the light / that shines from the sun" etc. Instead, we have "This is the sun." "This is the light that comes from the sun." "This is the tree that uses the light that comes from the sun to make its own food." And thus "...make its own food" is the final line on each subsequent cumulative page. Honestly, it feels like the author could have spent a bit more time with the classics of this genre, which do such a satisfying job of maintaining their repetitive structure throughout. This book eventually gets into its groove around the 4th or 5th page of text, but then loses it again at the end. I appreciate the attempt to bring things full circle, but it feels awkwardly done.
Overall, a lovely idea that just falls a bit short in execution. The illustrations are really the stand-out here - beyond their gorgeous cut-paper style, I love the way that they show a closeup of the new addition to the chain and then place it in the context of the larger scene on the facing page. 5 stars for the illustrations, but unfortunately only 3 stars for the writing... so I'll average it out to a 4. Gratitude to the publisher for the free ARC in exchange for an honest review. (