In examining the nature of the Protestant Reformation, and the lives of the Reformers, and evaluating it all from an Orthodox perspective, Fr. Josiah provides a most crucial text for converts, inquirers, catechumens, and protestants.

Refreshingly, this text doesn't make a pretense of some supposed academic 'neutrality', but lays all the cards on the table. Where the Reformers and their churches took a turn for the better -- rejecting various medieval papal innovations, for instance -- they are praised, and where they erred and departed from the common apostolic, orthodox deposit of faith, they are chastened. Though much of the text simply relays the historical development that gave rise to the various movements and churches, as well as the personalities of the Reformers.

One aspect of the book I found particularly exhilarating were in some of its critiques of the Reformation that are often ignored or under-emphasized. For instance, Fr. Josiah's taking to task Luther for his staunch anti-monasticism and degrading of the celibate life, along with his promotion of marriage to an extent out of accord with traditional Christianity, is fascinating. Here we see the Reformers rejecting, not a papal innovation, but universal Christianity which has an explicit Scriptural basis. Not only that, but we see how this aspect of the Reformation has borne bad fruit in modern Protestantism, which has no monasticism or expressly celibate vocation.

This is in addition to more traditional critiques of Protestantism, but those also find unapologetic, straightforward, and clear presentation that is rather rare in our more politically correct, diverse modern context.

Some of the most interesting and memorable material appears in small asides or footnotes. These divergences pepper the book with flavor and keep the historical main thrust from becoming too dry.

Highly recommended reading for Orthodox (especially in America or traditionally Protestant lands), and Protestants looking to better understand themselves. ( )