Tämä sivusto käyttää evästeitä palvelujen toimittamiseen, toiminnan parantamiseen, analytiikkaan ja (jos et ole kirjautunut sisään) mainostamiseen. Käyttämällä LibraryThingiä ilmaiset, että olet lukenut ja ymmärtänyt käyttöehdot ja yksityisyydensuojakäytännöt. Sivujen ja palveluiden käytön tulee olla näiden ehtojen ja käytäntöjen mukaista.
This volume was my favorite out of the three. Many it's because ithas two f my favorite authors L. Frank Baum and Virgina Woolf in it as comic book forms. I also liked more of the art in this volume as well. This even now makes me want to read some Anaïs Nin, D.H. Lawrence, and Infinite Jest too. Hell, maybe I'll read Ulysses sooner then later then I thought.
Still only 4 stars for this. It so worth the read if you don't mind samples, anthologies, and brief comic book adaptations of actual literature. ( )
I read the third installment of this interesting graphic project with more interest than the previous one, which I never finished, and not as much as the first. (Nineteenth century literature just doesn't really do it for me*). I am a child of the late twentieth century so many of the adapted books in this one were familiar to me. The quality varied. The most successful adaptations actually tried to present (or represent) the works in comic form: words and sequential pictures. The least successful were single, obscure images which contained very little meaning in the absence of the work they were supposedly derived from (or in some cases, even if I knew the work). Unfortunately there were quite a few of this type. They allowed for more pages and more works to be covered, but there was a cost. In these cases the editorial was more verbose and informative than the artwork; I found the editorial explaining both story and artwork. Fail! The worst was a poem rendered in 'radical' (ie. not readable) typography and no image at all. There were no comics which completely amazed me and a few whose style annoyed me (always a risk with anthologies). My favourites were ones which told a story: Ernest Hemingway's 'Living on $1000 a year in Paris' (Steve Rolston) and 'A Matter of Colour' (Dan Duncan), and H. G. Wells' ' The New Accelerator' (Cole Johnson). An OK collection, but the obscure single-image adaptations made chunks of it come across as an illustrated '1000 books to read before you die', a catalogue of canon rather than a collection.
Upon re-reading this in 2022 I would note that this is more of an art project than a comics project. I tried to appreciate the single-page graphics a little more but still found a disconnect between them and the works they portrayed.
* A notable exception is Walden by Henry Thoreau, which was nicely adapted in volume 2 of the Graphic Canon ( )
)
Google Books — Ladataan...
(3.62)
2
Still only 4 stars for this. It so worth the read if you don't mind samples, anthologies, and brief comic book adaptations of actual literature. (