Absolutely wonderful book. A must read for the church to know how the Bible has impacted the world in so many incredible ways. ( )

Although I’m familiar with how the Bible has shaped Western Civilization, particularly the culture of America, Mangalwadi introduced me to the depth of its effect and contrasted it with his homeland, India, and other developing nations that lack early biblical influence. The contrast between the hope and human dignity of traditional Western thought and the fear and fatalism of non-Western thought firmly stood out to me.

In college, I took a course on the cultural history of China and Japan. Often, I wondered why China’s technological progress stagnated. I figured its society became so caught up in memorizing Confucian ideas to pass the civil service exams that all other intellectual development was stifled. I sometimes would imagine how our world would have been different if China had not been so ethnocentric and had explored the lands to its west. (Only one emperor sent ships to East Africa. Beyond that, the Chinese didn’t consider the outside world worth exploring.) What if Western explorers, when rounding the Cape of Good Hope, had found a formidable Chinese armada ruling the Indian and China seas? That would have changed the course of the British Empire and world history.

Technological Advancement
In his book, Mangalwadi clarified that although many cultures developed some technologies, such as the Chinese creation of paper, the printing press, and gun power, much earlier than the Europeans, their worldviews failed to nurture inventions. Any scientific or technological pursuits accomplished by these cultures were merely to satisfy intellectual curiosity. The European monasteries, on the other hand, strove to invent time-saving machines to minimize toil and to have time for prayer. With the arrival of the Reformation, Christian compassion sought to lift men out of a life of drudgery because all men reflected the image of God and thus had dignity. “Necessity is the mother of invention” became a proverb in the West but not in the East. The non-Western cultures didn’t even see the need to help their fellow man through the development of medicine or just governments. This theme of the West's caring culture and how this attitude led to improving Western cultures was new to me.

For years I’ve wondered why developing nations inefficiently used their natural resources to make their country prosperous. Why did it take the Western powers to harvest the natural resources of Asia and Africa? When the Western powers gave these nations their independence, why did so many of them allow the infrastructure built by the Westerners to collapse? As a young teen in the 1980s, I heard a missionary say that within about a decade after Belgium pulled out of Zaire (now the Congo), the roads crumbled to the point that only ten percent of those that existed under colonial rule were usable. The century-old buildings in New Delhi are crumbling. Is the loss of a “caring” influence the source of this decay?

Honesty and Caring
A caring culture values honesty. During our process to adopt our daughter, I became profoundly aware of how Westerners hold honesty at a much higher level than other cultures. Many international adoption processes require bribe payments. A family who adopted from China needed to pay various in-country “fees” in cash. A family member, who adopted children from Ukraine, also had to carry cash to pay off officials. We didn’t bring much cash to India though we were expected to give money gifts to the orphanage caretakers. However, we had no idea how the Indian government spent the $7,000 country fee. I suspect a few government bureaucrats received money to keep the adoption process moving. That’s the way several governments seem to work. In the U.S., and some other Western nations, bribes are still looked down on. Author Mangalwadi points out that Western honesty surprises people from non-Western countries.

While waiting to bring our daughter home, I read several books about India. I became amazed that even though India could launch satellites in space, it cannot provide safe tap water even to a five-star hotel! I once asked an Indian immigrant why the Indian government couldn’t capture the monsoon rainwater, like we in Washington save snowmelt, in reservoirs for the dry seasons. He replied that it was not possible to do so. Perhaps that government doesn’t do so because they don’t have a sense of caring for its people, as Manalwadi pointed out.

Moreover, the Indian government, like many other nations, lacks the ability or desire to enforce its laws. National laws provide citizens freedom and protection, but the police and government officials either refuse or lack the courage to enforce them. The woman who supervised the orphanage where our daughter lived said that if a woman reported being raped by a local police officer, she’d more likely be raped by him instead of receiving justice.

This lack of caring perpetuates the spirit of fatalism. Why try improving one’s lot in life when one can’t fight fate? Something terrible will happen. It’s Eeyore on a cultural scale. I was shocked to learn from this author that in India, it is illegal for private parties to fundraise for disaster relief! That is so contrary to the American way of thinking. Whenever a disaster strikes in the US, Americans quickly send aid or go as a helping hand. Despite this national characteristic, so few Americans understand that their desire to help stems from a biblical worldview.

Preserve Our Biblical Heritage
The Western nations have turned their backs on their cultural heritage that laid the foundation for democracy, freedom, justice, and advanced science and technology. I often read about this rejection and wrestle in my mind how to restore the biblical foundations of my nation. When I look at our social-political problems and listen to cultural pundits, I keep asking myself: Why don’t they get it? Why can’t they see they are destroying the very foundations of our society? The epigraph Vishal Mangalwadi gave in chapter 1 explains the dilemma well.

For two hundred years, we have sawed and sawed and sawed at the branch we were sitting on. And in the end, much more suddenly than anyone had foreseen, our efforts were rewarded, and down we came. But unfortunately, there had been a little mistake: The thing at the bottom was not a bed of roses after all; it was a cesspool full of barbed wire . . . It appears that amputation of the soul isn’t just a simple surgical job, like having your appendix out. The wound tends to go septic.

—by George Orwell from his Notes on the Way, 1940

Westerners need to restore, preserve, and value our Judeo-Christian heritage. It’s the only one that provides hope and upholds human dignity. We must stand on the Bible as our firm foundation. All other cultural foundations are shifting sands of dismal fate.

https://lorindasponderings.com/2018/07/05/reading-response-the-book-that-made-yo... ( )

Este libro es IMPRESIONANTE, no debe ser tomado a la ligera y es imposible leerlo en una sola sentada.
Contiene tanta información y contenido histórico, filosófico, teológico que es imposible no parar para tomar notas, meditar y releer.
El autor es un renombrado filósofo, historiador y apologeta nacido en la India, y es sin lugar a dudas una de las mentes más brillantes de nuestra época.

Este libro rastrea el valor y la carga de importancia histórica que la Biblia ha traído a la humanidad a travez de la historia, es un puño solido en la mesa de los humanistas, ateos y vacíos pensamientos actuales.

Debe tenerlo en su biblioteca, debe leerlo y debe usarlo como consulta en su vida personal. ( )

Vishal Mangalwadi makes a big claim –– that the Bible created the Soul of Western Civilization. It definitely has influenced so much of the Western Civilization, no doubt. I think, if you have not heard of those authors in his book, then you might get a chance learn from him. However -- I'm aware of all those authors. There are so many great things about the Western Civilization, and I feel that he did not build a solid case to argue for it.

I found the blind assertions in his book to be ridiculous without backing it up with evidence and solid arguments. He would say, "X because of the Bible." That is circular, and vague. Eastern Christians (Orthodox) also had the Bible. Indeed, he could have argued that Bible was a vehicle that transmitted knowledge easily from West.

I felt –– he could have wrote his arguments and thoughts sharper. He missed to answer the, "How questions" in his book. A Giant leap and broad sweep of history. Overall, I do not think this is a solid book that proved his case, but a flimsy one without credible evidence. It's a hodge-pot mix of authors he learnt and read, and therefore his conclusion.

I did learn a new term, "Chronological Snobbery." it means, thinking the era we live is super-superior from the Past. Jawaharlal Nehru, also talks about it in his book, "Discovery of India."


Deus Vult,
Gottfried ( )

Vishal Mangalwadi makes a big claim –– that the Bible created the Soul of Western Civilization. It definitely has influenced so much of the Western Civilization, no doubt. I think, if you have not heard of those authors in his book, then you might get a chance learn from him. However -- I'm aware of all those authors. There are so many great things about the Western Civilization, and I feel that he did not build a solid case to argue for it.

I found the blind assertions in his book to be ridiculous without backing it up with evidence and solid arguments. He would say, "X because of the Bible." That is circular, and vague. Eastern Christians (Orthodox) also had the Bible. Indeed, he could have argued that Bible was a vehicle that transmitted knowledge easily from West.

I felt –– he could have wrote his arguments and thoughts sharper. He missed to answer the, "How questions" in his book. A Giant leap and broad sweep of history. Overall, I do not think this is a solid book that proved his case, but a flimsy one without credible evidence. It's a hodge-pot mix of authors he learnt and read, and therefore his conclusion.

I did learn a new term, "Chronological Snobbery." it means, thinking the era we live is super-superior from the Past. Jawaharlal Nehru, also talks about it in his book, "Discovery of India."


Deus Vult,
Gottfried ( )