It was interesting. I particularly enjoyed the parts dealing with Herschel and the bits of Ada Lovelace and Mary Shelley that crept in. If you want detailed biography on any one of these men, it will not suffice, but as a sort of biography of the period, it is entertaining and informative ( )

En el siglo xix, cuatro hombres, tras descubrir en la Universidad de Cambridge su pasión compartida por el progreso científico, deciden reunirse los domingos por la mañana para hablar del estado de la ciencia en Gran Bretaña y en el mundo. Inspirados por el gran político y reformador científico Francis Bacon, los miembros del Club de los desayunos filosóficos aunaron fuerzas para promover una nueva revolución científica. William Whewell, Charles Babbage, John Herschel y Richard Jones, investigadores de prestigio que llevaron a cabo importantes descubrimientos en distintos ámbitos, fueron los últimos filósofos naturales, que no sólo estuvieron a la vanguardia de la modernización de la ciencia, sino que engendraron una nueva especie: el científico. La historiadora Laura J. Snyder explora en este deslumbrante ensayo las motivaciones políticas y religiosas, las amistades y enemistades, y la sed de conocimiento y de poder que impulsaron a estos extraordinarios hombres, protagonistas de una auténtica revolución intelectual.

Quite a good collective biography, offering excellent contextual details to the biographical accounts of the members of the Philosophical Breakfast Club: Charles Babbage, John Herschel, William Whewell, and Richard Jones. Snyder makes clear just how interconnected this group was with each other throughout their careers, and how many things these men took an interest in and spent their time with. Well written and recommended. ( )

This was a very interesting book. Taken from the lives of four friends who were inventors, scientists, professors, teachers, citizens and political activists. It's a look back at the progression of science as a national investment. These four men contributed greatly to inventions and science and the concept that science should be funded and promoted through government assistance. Their activism in emphasizing and demonstrating that science was not simply a individual pursuit, but a worthy national pursuit; as the outcomes provided benefits to all citizens. Some of the scientific inventions (i.e., a mathematical capable machines that could solve calculations and the organization of a systematic predictor of tides) were not only "genius" for the time, but benefited commerce, etc. ( )

This is an excellent history of science, and particularly the emergence of the scientific method and the professional scientist, in the 19th century. The story is told through the lives of a group of friends who did more than most to make new scientific discoveries and to promote science as a specific discipline with its own methods and its own claim to be a valid full-time career. Whewell, Herschel, Babbage and Jones made significant discoveries and inventions in their own right across a bewildering array of scientific subjects, but more importantly were convinced of the need to put science on a formal footing, recognised by universities as subject matter for education and as an endeavour that could be pursued as a valid career. These men coined the term 'scientist' and set in place what we now understand as the scientific discipline and method.

Snyder writes well with a strong narrative rhythm and excellent use of source material. The interwoven lives of these great men and the development of their scientific interest and discoveries creates something of a page-turner. An excellent introduction to the history of science and there discoveries of the 19th century. ( )