Any idea why this was flagged?
Liity LibraryThingin jäseneksi, niin voit kirjoittaa viestin.
Tämä viestiketju on "uinuva" —viimeisin viesti on vanhempi kuin 90 päivää. Ryhmä "virkoaa", kun lähetät vastauksen.
It is certainly not a brilliant review, but it does try to give my opinion of the book. (On the other hand I think the other blue flag on that book is spam, and there is another review that should be blue flagged.)
Thanks to those who unflagged my review.
Edited to add link
They are obviously from a 10 point scale, but all the person put into the review field is the number. To me, this is still a review, so why did they get flagged?
It is not an obvious scale. It could be a shelf indicator, a box number, or anything else. Next you'll be defending prices as reviews, on grounds that if someone was willing to pay $13.99 for a book it must mean they liked it. If we're not just going to throw up our hands and call it the "Random stuff" field, then there needs to be a line somewhere, and I'm very comfortable drawing that line to exclude "r", "$7.99", or "3".
No, a price is definitely not a review. A simple code of ZB13, or Q2P5 is not a review. But if you look at all of the user's reviews and see numerous 7's, 8's, and 10's, would you not allow for a ten point scale?
Of course, this isn't to say I haven't sent a private message to the user asking for an explanation of their reviews. Whether I get anything will depend on if they even bother to log in any more.
In this case, I would have mentions the star rating system as well.
Have yet to get a reply outside of a single "It's my review. I'll do what I want" Most folks are just turning off their comments seems like when they get noticed.
edit: Just as an FYI, Rating needs to be looked at as it's nearly empty.