Kirjailijakuva

Katso täsmennyssivulta muut tekijät, joiden nimi on David J. Whittaker.

18+ teosta 232 jäsentä 3 arvostelua

Tekijän teokset

Mormon History (2001) — Tekijä — 18 kappaletta
Early Mormon Pamphleteering (2003) 4 kappaletta
BYU Studies - Vol. 20, No. 3 (Spring 1980) (1980) — Book Review Editor — 3 kappaletta
BYU Studies - Vol. 20, No. 2 (Winter 1980) (1980) — Book Review Editor — 3 kappaletta

Associated Works

Encyclopedia of Mormonism (1992) — Avustaja — 56 kappaletta
Joseph Smith Papers: Histories, 1832-1844, Vol. 1 (2012) — Toimittaja — 42 kappaletta
Encyclopedia of Latter-day Saint History (2000) — Avustaja — 40 kappaletta
Mapping Mormonism (2012) — Avustaja — 34 kappaletta
Joseph Smith, Jr.: Reappraisals After Two Centuries (2008) — Avustaja — 27 kappaletta
Historical Atlas of Mormonism (1994) — Avustaja — 22 kappaletta
Converted to Christ Through the Book of Mormon (1989) — Avustaja — 18 kappaletta
The Oxford Handbook of Mormonism (2015) — Avustaja — 15 kappaletta
Champion of Liberty (2009) — Avustaja — 13 kappaletta
Mormons in early Victorian Britain (1989) — Avustaja — 9 kappaletta
Parley P. Pratt and the Making of Mormonism (2011) — Avustaja — 5 kappaletta
BYU Studies - Volume 21, Number 4 (Fall 1981) (1981) — Book Review Editor, eräät painokset4 kappaletta
Mormon Identities in Transition (1996) — Avustaja — 4 kappaletta
BYU Studies - Volume 21, Number 2 (Spring 1981) (1981) — Book Review Editor, eräät painokset4 kappaletta
BYU Studies - Volume 21, Number 1 (Winter 1981) (1981) — Book Review Editor, eräät painokset; Avustaja — 4 kappaletta
BYU Studies - Volume 21, Number 3 (Summer 1981) (1981) — Book Review Editor, eräät painokset3 kappaletta
Journal of Mormon History - Volume 11 (1984) (1984) — Avustaja — 3 kappaletta
Journal of Mormon History - Vol. 27, No. 1, Spring 2001 (2001) — Avustaja — 2 kappaletta
BYU Studies - Vol. 20, No. 4 (Summer 1980) (1980) — Book Review Editor, eräät painokset; Avustaja — 2 kappaletta
Journal of Mormon History - Vol. 25, No. 2, Fall 1999 (1999) — Avustaja — 2 kappaletta
Journal of Mormon History - Volume 4 (1977) (1977) — Avustaja — 2 kappaletta
Journal of Mormon History - Volume 6 (1979) (1979) — Avustaja — 2 kappaletta
Journal of Mormon History - Vol. 39, No. 1, Winter 2013 (2013) — Avustaja — 2 kappaletta

Merkitty avainsanalla

Yleistieto

Jäseniä

Kirja-arvosteluja

This book was originally published in 2001, then spent some time online
in the University of Illinois Press free electronic library between 2001
and 2006, and has now been reprinted. It was meant as a companion to the
1,168 page bibliographic "Studies in Mormon History, 1830-1997,"
published in 2000 and apparently still available. The intention of the
book "is to provide a handbook for those starting a study in Mormon
history" (page ix).

Chapter One introduces us to 19th century writing, beginning with Eber
D. Howe's anti-Mormon book, "Mormonism Unvailed." It then continues with
LDS pamphleteers, manuscript histories, and newspapers. "The History of
the Church" is described as being "unsurpassed as a nineteenth-century
LDS work...[that] remains a basic research tool for beginning students
of the early Mormon experience" (page 9).

It goes on to talk about "middle way" books, which were written by
non-members, and fit somewhere between "Mormonism Unvailed" and "The
History of the Church," before continuing with LDS authors such as
Andrew Jensen and George Q. Cannon, and the establishment of the George
Q. Cannon and Sons printing press.

In Chapter Two, the first half of the 20th century is looked at. Here
the work of Nephi Anderson and B. H. Roberts is gone into, along with
the Improvement Era and "Essentials in Church History." Academic and
professional historians also did some important work during this time,
such as Richard T. Ely, Lowry Nelson, and Levi Edgar Young. Fawn Brodie,
Dale Morgan, and Juanita Brooks are given a couple of pages each,
referred to as "the three leading historians of Mormonism at
midcentury" (page 51).

Chapter three discusses what Moses Rischin called the "new Mormon
history." Leonard J. Arrington is credited with capturing the spirit of
this writing: "investigating the Mormon past in human or naturalistic
terms without rejecting its divinity." Shortly after this book was
originally published, Louis Midgley showed that Arrington was not
actually the author of that idea, and that he had spent many years
coming up with what it actually meant after he had been credited with
it, since it is an apparent contradiction. (See
http://www.fairlds.org/FAIR_Conferences/2001_Naturalistic_Terms.html .)

Arrington's work and that of others with him in the the LDS Historical
Department is discussed, along with reactions by leaders such as Boyd K.
Packer and Ezra Taft Benson. After the office was moved to BYU, many
other books and articles were produced, by authors such as Dean C.
Jessee and Thomas Alexander.

The BYU Department of History also made many contributions, as did the
Church Educational System and the College of Religious Education.
Scholars from the RLDS church (this book was written before it was
renamed to "Community of Christ") such as Robert B. Flanders and Richard
P. Howard did some important writing as well.

Space is also given to the work of people such as Jan Shipps, Lowell
Bennion, Lawrence Foster, Richard L. Bushman, and D. Michael Quinn, and
publications such as "Utah History Encyclopedia," as well as
computer-based databases. The beginnings of the Mormon History
Association are related, along with periodicals such BYU Studies,
Dialogue, the John Whitmer Historical Journal, the Improvement Era and
Ensign, and Sunstone.

Chapter Four discusses the challenges of Mormon biography. It gives a
history of LDS biographies, especially those of Joseph Smith and Brigham
Young. It talks about how biographies have changed over the centuries.
It touches on biographies of women, dissenters, and schismatics, as well
as autobiographies. It then outlines what the authors feel is still left
to be done: "the lives of the rank and file," women, and more LDS
leaders. And "the writing of LDS autobiographies is just getting
started" (page 140).

Chapter five was written by Armand L. Mauss. It talks about social
science literature. He points out that the studies on Mormons that have
been done outside the church have not yielded reliable data, having
either come from flawed samples or shortcomings in research methods, and
that Utah cannot be used to represent the church.

He talks about the church's Research Information Division, which does
produce reliable research, but is used internally by church leaders, and
very little information that has been produced has been made available
publicly. It has made contributions, however, by training young social
scientists and giving "a degree of legitimacy to the social scientific
perspective on religion, always suspect in the minds of conservative
church leaders and members" (page 163).

Mauss also covers continuing as well as newly developing directions in
LDS social science, such as family life, values, politics, racial and
ethnic relationships, and the roles of modern women. He then discusses
neglected topics: Mormon missiology; consequences of the exportation of
the Mormon religion; social stratification; organizational studies; and
deviance, discipline, and self control.

He ends his chapter with a statement that I wonder if he would still
agree with today: "All things considered, it seems unlikely that the
first decades of the twenty-first century will see the same rate of
growth in social science literature on the Mormons that occurred in the
final decades of the twentieth century" (page 182).

Appendix A and Appendix B go back over some of the same ground covered
earlier in the book, listing books and other sources of value to
historians. Appendix A evaluates "Mormon imprints" (although it also
talks about some anti-Mormon titles and other works published by non-LDS
publishers). It gives a history of publishing by the LDS church,
including scriptures, periodicals, hymnals, and almanacs. Appendix B
lists reference works, bibliographies, indexes, and even the
familysearch.org web site as places to help find things to aid in
research. A statement by Bernard De Voto that "a complete bibliography
of articles on Mormonism by qualified scholars would hardly fill one
page" (page 250) is indeed proven wrong.

In all, this book is a thorough (in some cases, perhaps too thorough)
walk through the writing of the history of the church up through the
close of the twentieth century. I found it to be very interesting and I
learned many things from it. However, it is rather unfortunate that it
was not updated when it was reprinted. Not only are the same
typographical errors still intact from the first printing ten years ago
(as verified by the archived e-book version at archive.org), but a great
deal has changed in the last ten years, and I believe the changes have
definitely been significant enough to warrant at least an additional
appendix, if not an actual revision to the text.

Although the book is very useful for an amateur historian (such as
myself) - or even still for a student, as was intended - to get up to
speed on what has gone on before us, I'm afraid the book's own
description of some outdated bibliographies now applies to itself: a
"useful signpost...to the past journey of Mormon scholarship, telling of
its quantity and quality when...[it] was produced." Still, I highly
recommend this book for anyone interested in Mormon history or Mormon
book collecting who wants to know more about the context in which the
literature was produced.
… (lisätietoja)
 
Merkitty asiattomaksi
atari_guy | May 11, 2021 |
The seemingly endless recitations of falsehoods that he quotes grow tedious. It soon grows obvious that the accusations he quotes are fabrications because they are not supported by evidence. The book also gives a clue why it is so popular to slander the "Mormons" - it sold a lot of novels.

"Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?" (Matthew 7:16) Do "Mormons" (The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) have high moral standards? Enough said on a tedious topic.… (lisätietoja)
 
Merkitty asiattomaksi
bread2u | Jul 1, 2020 |

Palkinnot

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Ronald W. Walker Contributor, Author
James B. Allen Author, Contributor, Editor
Ronald K. Esplin Author, Contributor
Andrew F. Ehat Editorial Intern, Contributor
John W. Welch Contributor, Editor
L. Jackson Newell Editor, Contributor
Keith Lawrence Editorial Intern
Richard G. Ellsworth Associate Editor
Linda King Newell Editor, Contributor
William Drew Editorial Intern
Linda Hunter Adams Editorial Assistant
Ernest L. Olson University Editor
Donald Q. Cannon Contributor, Introduction
Susan Easton Black Contributor
Eugene England Contributor
Jessie L. Embry Contributor
Mary Jane Woodger Contributor
Chad J. Flake Contributor
William G. Hartley Contributor
Armand L. Mauss Contributor
Ronald D. Dennis Contributor
Steven L. Olsen Contributor
Gary Topping Contributor
Edward L. Kimball Contributor
Dean C. Jessee Contributor
Stanley B. Kimball Contributor
Jill Mulvay Derr Contributor
Keith W. Perkins Contributor
Thomas E. Lyon Contributor
D. Gene Pace Contributor
Paul L. Anderson Contributor
William A. Wilson Contributor
Melvin J. Thorne Contributor
Elizabeth Mott Contributor
Alfred Bush Contributor
Margery W. Ward Contributor
Fred E. Woods Contributor
T. Jeffery Cottle Contributor
L. Madelon Brunson Contributor
Craig James Ostler Contributor
Kenneth L. Alford Contributor
RoseAnn Benson Contributor
Michael Edmonds Contributor
Larry W. Draper Contributor
Carol A. Edison Contributor
Michael A. Goodman Contributor
Kenneth W. Godfrey Contributor
Glenn N. Rowe Contributor
Ann Buttars Contributor
Sara Hallier Nyman Contributor
Scott C. Esplin Contributor
Lian Partlow Contributor
A. Burt Horsley Contributor
Richard O. Cowan Contributor
Brad Westwood Contributor
Richard L. Bushman Contributor
R. Lanier Britsch Contributor
Peter J. Blodgett Contributor
Richard E. Bennett Contributor
Bonnie Hardwick Contributor
David R. Hall Contributor
Richard G. Oman Contributor
Sherry Pack Baker Contributor
Joseph F. Darowski Contributor
John Sillito Contributor
Roger P. Minert Contributor
Erich Robert Paul Contributor
Theodore D. Moore Contributor
Janet C. Peterson Contributor
George Miles Contributor
Mark L. Staker Contributor
Casey P. Griffiths Contributor
Alan K. Parrish Contributor
Dennis Smith Contributor
Lisa Bolin Hawkins Contributor
Helen Walker Jones Contributor
Marden Clark Contributor
Lacee A. Harris Contributor
Wayne A. Larsen Contributor
Alvin C. Rencher Contributor
John F. Bluth Contributor
J. Neil Birch Contributor
Lawrence G. Coates Contributor
Lyndon W. Cook Contributor
William E. Evenson Contributor
Michael Fillerup Contributor
Chief Dan George Contributor
P. Jane Hafen Contributor
John B. Harris Contributor
Noel B. Reynolds Contributor
Bruce F. Webster Contributor
Steven C. Walker Contributor
Sally T. Taylor Contributor
Ishmael Stagner Contributor
Dianne Dibb Forbis Contributor
James N. Kimball Contributor
Keith Parry Contributor
Tim Layton Contributor
Robert P. Burton Contributor
D. Michael Quinn Contributor
C. Brooklyn Derr Contributor
S. S. Moorty Contributor
Dale Beecher Contributor
Dennis L. Lythgoe Contributor
Ronald O. Barney Contributor
Eric Jay Olson Contributor
Garth N. Jones Contributor
Emma Lou Thayne Contributor
Linda Sillitoe Contributor

Tilastot

Teokset
18
Also by
40
Jäseniä
232
Suosituimmuussija
#97,292
Arvio (tähdet)
4.0
Kirja-arvosteluja
3
ISBN:t
56

Taulukot ja kaaviot