Josh Barkan

I got a preview copy of this book through NetGalley because the story sounded pretty crazy: the author's wife cheats on him in Morocco, and a couple of years later he travels there to confront the man she slept with. And I don't know, the book might actually reach crazy at some point, but try as I might, I just couldn't muster the patience to get to that point. I gave up at almost exactly the halfway point.

In the first third of the book, Barkan recounts the events that led to his divorce and what happened immediately after... in MINUTE detail. What clothes he wears, what he orders at a coffee shop, how many drinks he has, what this friend says, what that neighbor says, etc. I empathize with the guy's pain, I really do, and his (ex) wife does sound like a piece of work, but reading his account felt like being buttonholed at a party by an acquaintance who won't stop talking about himself. Even in the very brief moment he tries to see the situation from his wife's point of view, he just says the same things he has been saying, only in the third person.

As Barkan nears the official divorce he finally goes out on some unsatisfying dates and has some brief flings in which he reveals some unsavory thoughts about the women he encounters. I'll give him credit for not sparing himself in these descriptions, but the accounts never rise above self-indulgence.

Barkan then travels to Mexico, where he meets a wonderful woman who nurtures him back into normalcy (although I guess not fully, since he will still end up going to Morocco!). I reached the end of my patience when he takes this new woman to a luxury restaurant and it starts raining heavily while they're sitting outdoors. He describes the waiters getting soaked as they rush to set up awnings to protect him and his date, and he thinks to himself that these servants don't mind getting wet because they're joining in the happiness the couple is feeling at that moment. And that's when I realized that, like the waiters, I too was indulging a man who can only think of himself, and I put the book down for good.… (lisätietoja)

If it were not for Blogging for Books, I am not sure this one would have been in my TBR stack. While the cover is an interesting one, the book never crossed my radar as a must get. Since it was an offering on the site, I figured- why not?

Mexico stories by Josh Barkan should have been called "Cartel stories" as each short story is about how an ordinary person just trying to get by in Mexico has a cartel figure pop into his/her life and now must figure out what to do.

We have stories of a chef who must prepare an outstanding dish for a cartel leader only using two ingredients or he loses his life. A story of a woman carved and what her scars mean. A doctor who must choose to save the life of a cartel leader. Along with many other stories.

Each story did have a uniqueness to it and were well written, but there was just something off about the book as a whole for me. After a few stories, I found myself wanting the book to end as each one pretty much has the same plot, but the story is now a new situation, namely how is this person going to overcome the cartel? It got a bit tedious after a bit and I wonder if that is why the book seems to be getting negative reviews on Goodreads. It just becomes too much.

I kept feeling that if the book is called Mexico, Mexico should be a "character" of some kind. The country barely plays a role, except here is where these two people will now square off. This is why I suggested a title change might be in order. Mexico is simply a backdrop and doesn't pop into the story.

These are not bad stories by far, although I did feel the doctor one has been told so many times, but they were too similar to each other. I also would not call the book a fun read. Many of the stories are depressing and there isn't much hope contained within them. For example, the chef overcomes the odds, but what is the payoff besides being able to live? It just ends with the cartel leader leaving and t he chef facing someone else in the restaurant. There isn't guilt or shame, but life goes on.

I would have a hard time recommending this one to people, but I can see an audience. I just wasn't one on that list. I gave this one 3 stars.… (lisätietoja)

True to my word, I am making a conscious effort to read more short stories. I was very excited to hear about this series of short stories. I don't know much about Mexico except what is on the news so I was really looking forward to reading diverse stories on the culture and the people who live in Mexico in the hopes that it would give me a new perspective.

The unforgettable characters in this story collection range from chef to architect to high school teacher to beauty queen (and everything in between). They are all trying to lead simple lives. Yet somehow crime has a way of intruding into their lives - and the way it shapes them is unimaginable. Time and time again, the walls between "ordinary life" and violence are shown to be more closely linked than one might like, and the consequences of these connections are life-changing.

While the characters and the stories are interesting, the constant recurring theme of violence and drug cartels caused all of the different stories to meld into one. Because of this effect, the short stories began to lose their charm. I agree that a collection should have some central theme but the stories themselves had to do with the same things and the same actions, and after a while, there really wasn't anything new being presented. Some of the characters and their experiences left really strong impressions in me, which was definitely a positive thing! I wish this novel wasn't so fixated on the negatives of Mexico; while there are loads of drug cartels, there is also beauty and charm and culture in this country and none of this was really expressed well in this story. So while the characters and the writing style were interesting, the overall collection left me disappointed because of its dismal portrayal of Mexico and its lack of uniqueness between the different short stories.

I received this novel as an advanced copy from Blogging for Books and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

For more reviews, visit: www.veereading.wordpress.com… (lisätietoja)

Mexico: Stories by Josh Barkan is a collection of fictional short stories, all taking place in Mexico. The collection was awarded runner up for the Juniper Prize for Fiction, 2014, t and runner up for the Grace Paley Prize for Short Fiction, 2014.

A collection of short stories are always difficult to write about because the stories range in interest and quality. Mexico: Stories by Josh Barkan is no exception, as the talented writer tell his tales.

The Mexico which Mr. Barkan depicts is violent, poor and hopeless, I don’t know why anyone would want to live there. The stories try to tell about slices of life in Mexico, but they all have a common theme of violence, drug lords and constant daily fear and uncertainty.

I’m not sure how realistic these stories are, truthfully, I hope never to find out. Many of the stories are written in first person which allows the reader to go into the protagonist’s head.

None of the stories, I thought, were especially memorable – but I’m not a big fan of short stories. There was also no overreaching arc which ties the stories together with the exception that they all take place in Mexico.

The stories seemed to be as if the author started writing a non-fiction narrative and then changed it midway, it worked some of the time, but other times it did not. The rating I gave is an overall average for the book, as I mentioned before, short stories collections are difficult to grade.

For more reviews and bookish posts please visit: http://www.ManOfLaBook.com… (lisätietoja)